Supreme Court upholds suspension of Judge Kropyvna over property in Kozyn

Supreme Court upholds suspension of Judge Kropyvna over property in Kozyn
Supreme Court upholds suspension of Judge Kropyvna over property in Kozyn

Grand Chamber confirms lawfulness of High Council of Justice actions

The Grand Chamber of the Supreme Court issued a ruling denying the appeal of Lyudmyla Kropyvna, a judge at the Northern Court of Appeal for Commercial Matters. This decision upheld the ruling of the court of first instance, which had previously confirmed the lawfulness of the actions taken by the High Council of Justice (HCJ) regarding Kropyvna's temporary suspension from exercising judicial powers.

The ruling entered into legal force upon its adoption and is not subject to further appeal. This became known from the decision dated 3 November 2026 in case No. 990/532/25.

Circumstances of the case: suspicion of illegal enrichment

The court reviewed the case materials, where a pre-trial investigation is ongoing on suspicion of illegal enrichment and declaring false information on an especially large scale. According to the prosecution, in December 2021, Lyudmyla Kropyvna acquired ownership of land plots and a residential building in the urban-type settlement of Kozyn in Kyiv Oblast.

The investigation and valuation documents indicate that the value of these assets significantly exceeded the judge's lawful income. The petition cited a sum of USD 891,300, which at the National Bank of Ukraine exchange rate at the time amounted to UAH 23,962,244. The discrepancy between this figure and her lawful income was estimated at UAH 16,341,917.

Simultaneously, in her 2021 declaration, Kropyvna stated the value of the assets as UAH 8,199,999. The prosecution alleged that the judge provided inaccurate data regarding calculations and financial obligations. The defence, in turn, relied on an alternative expert valuation of the real estate at UAH 8,575,762, refused to acknowledge any risks or grounds for suspension, and claimed bias on the part of the authorities.

Chronology of court rulings

In October 2025, the High Council of Justice partially granted the petition of the head of the Specialised Anti-Corruption Prosecutor's Office (SAP) and temporarily suspended Lyudmyla Kropyvna from exercising judicial powers until 22 November 2025.

In December 2025, the court of first instance reviewed the appeal against this HCJ decision and refused to cancel it. Subsequently, the case was referred to the Grand Chamber of the Supreme Court.

Grand Chamber arguments

When issuing the final decision, the Grand Chamber of the Supreme Court concluded that the HCJ's decision contained the grounds and motives prescribed by law. The court noted that the Council acted strictly within its powers: it verified the existence and content of the materials and assessed the risks, without interfering in the assessment of guilt or replacing the court hearing the criminal case on the merits.

The Supreme Court emphasised that the assessment of the sufficiency and admissibility of evidence, as well as the determination of the suspect's guilt or innocence, falls within the competence of the court within the main criminal proceedings.

Comments

No comments yet. Be the first!

Leave a comment

Links are not allowed in comments. The editors may remove comments without explanation.
Back to top ↑