On 4 November 2026, the Kyiv District Administrative Court issued a ruling that upheld the tax sanctions imposed on the company owning the Yabluka electronics store. The court denied LLC "Armstrong" its claim to cancel fines totalling 1,129,061 hryvnias.
Reasons for the tax audit
Control measures began in April 2025, when officials from the Main Directorate of the State Tax Service in Cherkasy Oblast conducted a physical inspection of the store located at 208/1 Shevchenko Boulevard, Cherkasy. The business entity, registered under Form No. 20-OPP, belonged to LLC "Armstrong".
The basis for the control was a letter from the State Tax Service of Ukraine containing information about possible violations during the sale of Apple products. Specifically, it mentioned the absence of documents confirming the origin and proper accounting of expensive equipment.
Tax authority decision and fine amounts
Following the inspection, the Main Directorate of the State Tax Service in Kyiv issued two tax notification-decisions on 3 June 2025:
- Document No. 0509570707 — a fine of 1,127,021 UAH for violating Article 3, Clause 12 of the Law on RRO. The violation was identified as the sale of goods without proper accounting and the failure to provide the relevant documents at the start of the inspection;
- Document No. 0509580707 — a fine of 2,040 UAH for the repeated failure to provide documents upon the tax authority's request within a year.
Court arguments against the company's position
LLC "Armstrong" challenged the legality of the inspection appointment, claiming that the order did not clearly define the period and object of control, and that the tax officers exceeded the scope of the inspection. However, the court did not support these arguments.
The judicial authorities established that Order No. 946-p dated 14 April 2025 was issued in accordance with the requirements of the Tax Code of Ukraine. A copy of the order and the referrals was handed over to the sales consultant, who conducted settlement operations, for signature.
The court noted that documents for the goods needed to be provided at the start of the inspection. The waybill for movement No. 46 dated 11 April 2025, provided by the company, lacked the necessary details and the specific address of the recipient in Cherkasy. Meanwhile, "Kyiv Main Warehouse" was not specified in Form No. 20-OPP.
The court also emphasised that the tax authority's powers during a physical inspection of compliance with the procedure for conducting settlement operations include monitoring the accounting of goods stock directly at the place of sale and the documents confirming their origin.
Thus, the claim by LLC "Armstrong" was left unsatisfied, and the tax notification-decisions with fines totalling 1,129,061 UAH remained in force.
Comments
No comments yet. Be the first!