Taran criticises Economy Ministry for forwarding SBU queries on Stynava deposit

Taran criticises Economy Ministry for forwarding SBU queries on Stynava deposit
Taran criticises Economy Ministry for forwarding SBU queries on Stynava deposit

Economy Ministry shifts responsibility to State Geological Agency

Political expert and military figure Viktor Taran shared his impressions of new media investigations dedicated to potential corruption schemes surrounding the Stynava oil deposit. In his view, the most interesting aspect of the situation was not so much the latest refusal by "Ukrnafta", but rather the reaction of the Ministry of Economy to an official appeal from the Security Service of Ukraine.

According to journalist Boris Kushniruk, the SBU approached the ministry with a request to verify the circumstances of issuing special permits and the decision-making process by state bodies. However, the Ministry, headed by Oleksandr Kravchenko, responded that such a verification falls outside its powers. In response, the ministry forwarded all materials to the State Geological Agency, whose decisions were the subject of the inquiries.

«Прочитали новий матеріал Бориса Кушнірука про Стинавське родовище, і найцікавішим у ньому виявилася навіть не чергова відмова "Укрнафті", а те, як Мінекономіки відреагувало на офіційне звернення СБУ. За даними Кушнірука, Служба безпеки попросила перевірити обставини навколо спецдозволів і рішень державних органів. Міністерство Олександра Кравченка відповіло, що така перевірка виходить за межі його компетенції, і переслало матеріали до Держгеонадр, тобто саме тим, чиї рішення і викликали запитання. Це приблизно як попросити футбольного арбітра перевірити, чи не підсуджував він сам собі, і вважати питання закритим» (We read Boris Kushniruk's new article on the Stynava deposit, and the most interesting thing in it turned out to be not even the latest refusal by "Ukrnafta", but how the Economy Ministry reacted to the official appeal from the SBU. According to Kushniruk, the Security Service asked to verify the circumstances surrounding the special permits and decisions of state bodies. Oleksandr Kravchenko's ministry responded that such a verification is outside its competence, and forwarded the materials to the State Geological Agency, i.e. precisely to those whose decisions raised questions. This is roughly like asking a football referee to check whether he was refereeing himself, and considering the matter closed), Taran quotes in his post.

Disputes over "Pari Naftogaz" block auction

The expert recalled that "Ukrnafta" had already twice attempted to put the Stynava deposit up for open auction. Both times, applications were left unconsidered due to legal inconsistencies related to the special permit of the company "Pari Naftogaz". This structure is linked to the family of Mykola Zlochevskyi.

According to Taran, the state has still failed to resolve this issue, which directly affects competition for access to strategic subsoil. To the geological and legal inconsistencies, a managerial one has been added.

«Тепер до геологічних і юридичних суперечностей додалася ще й управлінська. Хто має перевіряти рішення, якщо кожна установа вказує на компетенцію іншої? Здавалося б, звернення СБУ мало стати саме тим сигналом, після якого уряд налагодить зрозумілий порядок реагування, але поки ми бачимо лише пересилання документів і невирішену проблему» (Now, to the geological and legal inconsistencies, a managerial one has been added. Who should verify the decisions if each institution points to the competence of another? It would seem that the SBU's appeal should have been the very signal after which the government would establish a clear order of response, but so far we see only the forwarding of documents and an unresolved problem), the expert noted.

Budget losses and bureaucratic ping-pong

Viktor Taran is convinced that Ukrainian bureaucracy has demonstrated its ability to "defeat" any problem if it is forwarded from office to office for long enough. However, as the expert notes, when it comes to significant financial losses, bureaucratic ping-pong ceases to be funny.

According to Kushniruk's estimates, over one billion hryvnia in budget losses is at stake. Under such conditions, bureaucratic ping-pong ceases to be funny, and the essence of the issue comes down not to the quality of correspondence, but to the quality of state governance in general.

«Тож від міністра Кравченка хотілося б почути не відписку про компетенцію, а чітку відповідь, хто в державі відповідає за долю цього родовища» (Therefore, from Minister Kravchenko, one would like to hear not a boilerplate response about competence, but a clear answer as to who in the state is responsible for the fate of this deposit), Taran concluded.

Comments

No comments yet. Be the first!

Leave a comment

Links are not allowed in comments. The editors may remove comments without explanation.
Back to top ↑