The results of an audit of the activities of the Kyiv City State Administration (KMSA) for 2018–2020 confirmed financial violations in the capital's digitalisation sector. The total amount of identified violations is UAH 274.86m, equivalent to approximately US$10m.
Budget funds spent without results
As of 2020, none of the 25 software products developed with local budget funds during 2015–2018 had been put into industrial operation. Despite the money being spent and acts of completed works being signed, no real functioning result was obtained from these investments.
Financial flows were absorbed by a narrow circle of individuals where an official, a public expert and a contractor acted as a single team. On the electronic procurement platform Prozorro, competition for this group was effectively created by the group itself.
Roles of scheme participants
Yuriy Nazarov joined the KMSA in 2015, and from 3 March 2017 headed the Department of Information and Communication Technologies. It was this department that placed orders for software development through the municipal enterprise "Main Information and Computing Centre" (MICC).
Serhiy Loboyko acted on behalf of the public. He headed the public organisation "Centre for Innovation Development" and held the position of adviser to the First Deputy Head of the KMSA, Hennadiy Plys, and later Mykola Povoroznyk. Since the first deputies approved programme budgets, Loboyko persuaded them of the need for another platform, publicly appearing as an independent expert supporting it.
Oleksandr Yefremov, known as the developer of the Diia portal, provided the contractor. He owned 90% of Kitsoft LLC and 92% of Computer Information Technologies LLC (KIT). Another company belonging to this group was EF DI AI Company (FDI). FDI's charter capital was only UAH 15,000, its staff numbered between 2 and 5 people, yet the company received contracts from the MICC worth over UAH 130m.
Simulation of competition via a common manager
The link between Kitsoft and FDI was ensured by Mykola Kozlov. From the end of 2017, he effectively managed Kitsoft as executive director. Loboyko proposed him for this position, where Kozlov had previously worked as chief IT expert.
In April 2018, Kozlov became executive director of FDI. At the same time, his income was formed by the companies KIT and KIT Group. Thus, the head of the firm supposedly competing with Yefremov's companies for Kyiv millions was actually receiving funding from these same structures.
Comments
No comments yet. Be the first!