Court ruling on publications regarding the suspect
The Pecherskyy District Court of Kyiv issued a ruling partially upholding the lawsuit filed by Dmytro Borzikh, a former deputy chief military prosecutor who currently works as a lawyer. The claims were brought against the media outlet ZN UA and Inna Vedernikova, editor of the domestic politics department.
Publication obligations and ruling details
Judge Oleksiy Sokolov ordered the editorial team to completely remove two news items: one regarding the notification of suspicion to Borzikh by the National Anti-Corruption Bureau (NABU), and another regarding the preventive measure in the form of bail in the amount of 10 million hryvnias selected by the High Anti-Corruption Court. The court also ordered the removal of certain fragments from other materials, specifically from the investigation "The Case of Hacker-Lawyers. How NABU Found Parasites", and to publish a retraction.
However, in the text of the ruling itself, the court confirmed that on 1 April 2025, NABU did indeed notify Dmytro Borzikh of suspicion of organising unauthorised access to the Unified State Register of Court Decisions. Thus, the fact about which ZN UA informed the audience is not disputed. Nevertheless, the court ruled that the disclosure of the plaintiff's name and other data allowing his identification constitutes a violation of his rights. Certain statements contained in the journalistic materials were also deemed false.
Financial aspects and chronology
The plaintiff sought reimbursement of 500,000 hryvnias in court costs, of which 300,000 was the cost of legal assistance. Currently, the court ordered the recovery of 33,280 hryvnias in court fees in favour of Borzikh: 30,617.60 hryvnias from ZN UA and 2,662.40 hryvnias from Inna Vedernikova. The issue of reimbursing the remaining costs has been left for separate consideration, subject to the submission of appropriate evidence.
The ruling was issued on 13 October, but the full text, dated 16 October, became available to the defendants' lawyers only on 16 November, i.e. a month later. The defence intends to appeal this decision.
Defence reaction and legal aspects
ZN UA lawyer Yevhen Vorobyov claims that the court effectively ignored the evidence provided by the editorial team, as well as arguments regarding the public interest in this case.
The situation where the court confirms the fact of the suspicion notice but simultaneously orders the removal of news about it raises a fundamental question again: do Ukrainian media have the right to name suspects in criminal proceedings that constitute significant public interest?
The problem is embedded, among other things, in Part 4 of Article 296 of the Civil Code of Ukraine, which restricts the use of the name of a suspect or accused until a guilty verdict enters into legal force. Without proper consideration of public interest and European standards of freedom of speech, the application of this provision creates a dangerous instrument for restricting journalistic activity.
Comments
No comments yet. Be the first!