Kyiv City State Administration audit reveals 275 million hryvnia in digitalisation violations linked to Yefremov

Kyiv City State Administration audit reveals 275 million hryvnia in digitalisation violations linked to Yefremov
Kyiv City State Administration audit reveals 275 million hryvnia in digitalisation violations linked to Yefremov

Millions for non-functional software

Auditors of the Kyiv City State Administration (KMSA) recorded financial violations in the digitalisation sector totalling 274.86 million hryvnia (approximately 10 million US dollars) for the period 2018–2020. Notably, as of 2020, none of the 25 software products purchased with budget funds in 2015–2018 had been put into industrial operation. In effect, the city paid money and signed acts of completed works, but there was nothing to use the results for.

A closed circle of interests

The investigation showed that funds were received by a narrow group of individuals where officials, public experts and contractors functioned as a single team. Competition in state procurement via ProZorro was imitative: firms that formally competed with each other belonged to the same group of influence.

Three figures played a key role in this mechanism:

  • Yuriy Nazarov, who worked at the KMSA from 2015 and headed the Department of Information and Communication Technologies from 3 March 2017. His unit ordered software development through the municipal enterprise "Main Information and Computing Centre" (MICC).
  • Serhiy Loboyko, who represented public interests. He headed the public organisation "Centre for Innovation Development" and held the position of advisor to the First Deputy Head of the KMSA, Hennadiy Plys, and later Mykola Povoroznyk. It was the first deputy heads who approved the budgets for IT projects. Loboyko convinced management of the need for new platforms, appearing publicly as an independent expert supporting them.
  • Alexander Yefremov, the developer of the "Diia" portal, who provided the contractors. He owns 90% of Kitsoft LLC and 92% of Computer Information Technologies LLC (KIT). Another firm in this group operated under the name "EF DI AI Company" (FDI). With a charter capital of only 15,000 hryvnia and a staff of 2 to 5 people, FDI received contracts from the MICC worth over 130 million hryvnia.

Head of two "competitors"

The link between Kitsoft LLC and FDI was maintained by Mykola Kozlov. From the end of 2017, he effectively managed Kitsoft as executive director. It was Loboyko who proposed him for this position, as Kozlov had previously worked as the chief IT expert at Loboyko's centre.

In April 2018, Kozlov became the executive director of FDI. However, his income was generated by the companies KIT and KIT Group, which belonged to Yefremov. Thus, the head of a firm that formally competed with Yefremov's companies for Kyiv's millions was financially dependent on those same companies.

It should be noted that over so many years, almost none of the recipients of budget funds have faced liability for the violations identified.

Comments

No comments yet. Be the first!

Leave a comment

Links are not allowed in comments. The editors may remove comments without explanation.
Back to top ↑