EMN: EU countries apply different rules for counting temporary protection time towards permanent residence

EMN: EU countries apply different rules for counting temporary protection time towards permanent residence
EMN: EU countries apply different rules for counting temporary protection time towards permanent residence

For Ukrainians in Europe as a result of the war, the conditions for obtaining a long-term or permanent residence permit vary significantly depending on the country. A key aspect is whether years spent under temporary protection status are counted towards the total period required to secure a stable status.

On 1 November 2026, the European Migration Network (EMN) published an analytical review that systematised the approaches of 23 member and observer states of the network. It emerged that the situation is ambiguous: some countries fully count this period, others operate under partial or conditional rules, while a third group currently does not include the time under protection towards the required period at all.

Five states where protection time is fully counted

In five European countries, legal residence under temporary protection is fully included in the term required to obtain permanent or long-term status. This group includes:

  • Germany: the entire period of residence is counted towards the five-year term for obtaining a permanent permit.
  • Lithuania: years of legal residence with temporary protection are fully included in the required five years.
  • Estonia: the entire period of residence under a permit issued on the basis of temporary protection is taken into account when processing long-term resident status.
  • Spain: the entire validity period of the residence card issued within the framework of temporary protection is included in the five-year period.
  • Hungary: the period of such residence is fully taken into account for obtaining a national or European long-term residence card, provided that other legislative criteria are met.

It is worth noting that even five years of residence do not guarantee the automatic granting of permanent status. The applicant is obliged to meet all the requirements of the specific state's legislation.

Countries with additional conditions and partial counting

In a number of states, previous years of residence may be counted only partially or after changing the migration status to another type of permit.

Czechia counts the time of residence under temporary protection at half value after obtaining a special long-term permit. That is, four years of temporary protection will be counted as two years. After switching to the special permit, each year of residence will be counted in full.

In Austria, the entire previous period of temporary protection can be included in the required term if the citizen switches to the Red-White-Red Card Plus.

In Slovakia, to obtain long-term status, Ukrainians must first obtain a standard residence permit with a defined purpose (work, study, entrepreneurship, etc.). The relevant activity must be pursued for at least six months before the end of temporary protection and continued at the time of submitting the application. After changing status, previous years of temporary protection will be included in the continuous residence period.

The government of Ireland has agreed an alternative residence permit for Ukrainians who plan to stay in the country regardless of temporary protection. The requirements include: residence under protection for at least one year, having own or independently secured housing, and work or entrepreneurial activity during the last six months. A minimum annual income of €29,432 before tax has also been established. The period of residence under the new permit will be counted for obtaining citizenship and the right to remain in the country without time limit.

In France, there is no single automatic transition mechanism. Each application is considered individually. During the extension of temporary protection, local prefectures check whether a person has grounds for obtaining a standard card, particularly through work or family circumstances.

Where temporary protection is not counted

According to EMN data, in 12 countries, years of residence under temporary protection are currently not included in the term required to obtain permanent or long-term status. These are:

Poland, Belgium, the Netherlands, Finland, Italy, Greece, Luxembourg, Sweden, Bulgaria, Croatia, Cyprus, and Latvia.

Meanwhile, in Latvia, legislative changes are being considered that may allow Ukrainians to obtain a national permanent residence card after five years of residence under temporary protection. Until the relevant amendments are adopted, this period is not counted.

Slovenia is mentioned separately in the review. There, Ukrainians must first switch to a temporary permit with a specific purpose of stay. However, final clarifications regarding the counting of previous years of temporary protection have not yet been approved.

Prospects for changes at the EU level

At the European Union level, an update to the Long-Term Residents Directive is being considered. The proposed draft provides for taking into account all periods of legal residence, including years spent under temporary protection.

However, the relevant changes have not yet been adopted. Therefore, when processing documents, Ukrainians must follow the current rules of the country in which they plan to obtain long-term or permanent status.

Comments

No comments yet. Be the first!

Leave a comment

Links are not allowed in comments. The editors may remove comments without explanation.
Back to top ↑